The Old Fashioned

Name: The Old Fashioned
Address: 23 N Pinckney St #1, Madison, WI
Telephone: 16083104545
Rating: 4.32222222222222

Restaurants

4.3(7,116 reviews across 2 platforms)

85.8

Overall Score

Review Breakdown by Platform

Google

4.5

4,628 reviews

Updated 2/23/2026

Yelp

4.1

2,488 reviews

Updated 2/23/2026

Other Restaurants in Madison

Burger King

Restaurants

87.7

Score

4.6(13,624 reviews)Popular

G4.6

RED

Restaurants

84.7

Score

4.5(2,491 reviews)Popular

G4.7Y4.3

North and South Seafood & Smokehouse

Restaurants

84.2

Score

4.6(1,857 reviews)Popular

G4.6Y4.5

Ian's Pizza

Restaurants

83.9

Score

4.6(3,130 reviews)Popular

G4.6

Contact Info

(608) 310-4545

[email protected]

theoldfashioned.com

23 N Pinckney St #1, Madison, WI

Is this your business?

Claim your listing to manage reviews and contact info

Claim This Business

Request a Quote

Describe your project and The Old Fashioned will get back to you.