Selective Insurance Company
Insurance Agents
4.4(1,649 reviews across 1 platform)
79.4
Overall Score
Review Breakdown by Platform
4.4
1,649 reviews
Updated 2/23/2026
Other Insurance Agents in Buffalo
Geico Car Insurance
Insurance Agents
87.3
Score
4.8(4,218 reviews)Popular
G4.8
Austin Czaja - State Farm Insurance Agent
Insurance Agents
84.1
Score
5.0(350 reviews)Popular
G5.0Y5.0
Sheridan Benefits
Insurance Agents
80.9
Score
5.0(288 reviews)Popular
G5.0
Sheridan Benefits LLC
Insurance Agents
79.3
Score
5.0(175 reviews)Popular
G5.0
Contact Info
Request a Quote
Describe your project and Selective Insurance Company will get back to you.